Metadata (XMP / IPTC / EXIF) Editor improvements
Posted: Wed Jan 03, 2007 7:24 am
I'm running XnView 1.9 beta 6 and noticed a few missing "features" in the Edit IPTC data dialog.
Accessibility / Usability / Keyboard Shortcuts
- The keyboard controls don't work as expected. Ctrl+Tab should cycle through the tabs, yet it functions like the Ctrl key is not pressed.
- No fields except the Write button have an associated keyboard command.
- The Write button acts like an "Apply" button; there should be the same buttons as a standard Windows dialog has... OK (save and close), Apply (save only), Cancel (close only). Adding the additional button saves one step in the update process and would give a more consistent look and feel.
I'm still a little lost on the actual definition of all the IPTC fields (what's the actual definition of "credit” and the difference in credit and source); however, it appears that Object Name should be the file name. If that is correct then it would be very nice to have a <filename> value like the Date Created value supports the <modified> value.
Quick Lists [see http://newsgroup.xnview.com/viewtopic.php?t=4453]
The Keywords and Captions tabs have this new feature as does the Date Created and Release Date fields, but it should be applied to many other fields. The old, yet still great EXIFer implemented this. It is a great time saver and helps tremendously with consistency. Essentially, just add the “>>” button to every applicable field and add custom values to the drop down list like EXIFer does.
Multiple metadata standards
When editing of EXIF and XMP data is added, it would be a good idea to apply changes to all applicable fields to maintain consistency, backward compatibility and help with apps that don't support one of the standards. So, for instance, when writing an IPTC caption, it would be saved in the corresponding IPTC, EXIF, XMP, and JPEG Comment fields.
I’ll be glad to split this into multiple threads if it will be more manageable to track.
Much thanks for the awsome app that XnView is!
Accessibility / Usability / Keyboard Shortcuts
- The keyboard controls don't work as expected. Ctrl+Tab should cycle through the tabs, yet it functions like the Ctrl key is not pressed.
- No fields except the Write button have an associated keyboard command.
- The Write button acts like an "Apply" button; there should be the same buttons as a standard Windows dialog has... OK (save and close), Apply (save only), Cancel (close only). Adding the additional button saves one step in the update process and would give a more consistent look and feel.
I'm still a little lost on the actual definition of all the IPTC fields (what's the actual definition of "credit” and the difference in credit and source); however, it appears that Object Name should be the file name. If that is correct then it would be very nice to have a <filename> value like the Date Created value supports the <modified> value.
Quick Lists [see http://newsgroup.xnview.com/viewtopic.php?t=4453]
The Keywords and Captions tabs have this new feature as does the Date Created and Release Date fields, but it should be applied to many other fields. The old, yet still great EXIFer implemented this. It is a great time saver and helps tremendously with consistency. Essentially, just add the “>>” button to every applicable field and add custom values to the drop down list like EXIFer does.
Multiple metadata standards
When editing of EXIF and XMP data is added, it would be a good idea to apply changes to all applicable fields to maintain consistency, backward compatibility and help with apps that don't support one of the standards. So, for instance, when writing an IPTC caption, it would be saved in the corresponding IPTC, EXIF, XMP, and JPEG Comment fields.
I’ll be glad to split this into multiple threads if it will be more manageable to track.
Much thanks for the awsome app that XnView is!