Page 1 of 1

Hot folders -- Convert button only active when a file loaded on the Input tab

Posted: Mon Aug 21, 2023 8:48 am
by cday
When XnConvert is opened and configured to use the Input tab Hot folder option, the Convert button remains greyed out unless a file is loaded on the Input tab.

Expected operation is that after specifying one or more hot folders, the Convert button is active, enabling the Hot folder option to be used independently.

Tested XnView 1.98.

Re: Hot folders -- Convert button only active when a file loaded on the Input tab

Posted: Wed Aug 23, 2023 3:34 pm
by xnview
I don't understand, the convert process starts automatically, no need to click on convert button

Re: Hot folders -- Convert button only active when a file loaded on the Input tab

Posted: Wed Aug 23, 2023 4:54 pm
by cday
xnview wrote: Wed Aug 23, 2023 3:34 pm I don't understand, the convert process starts automatically, no need to click on convert button
Ok, but not sufficiently obvious?

It seems logical that operation should only start when Convert is clicked.

Perhaps for consistency monitoring should only start after clicking on Convert... :?:

user0?

Re: Hot folders -- Convert button only active when a file loaded on the Input tab

Posted: Wed Aug 23, 2023 8:21 pm
by user0
yeah.. state of 'Hot folders' mode definitely is not representative enough

there are few ways to show active state (I will use xnview UI as example):
  • if tool runs in background (not our case)
    • tray icon
    • show some indication in app (eg in titlebar)
    • enabled Conver button
      I would expect mode activation via pressing Convert button (maybe change name to Run/Watch when checkbox checked)
  • if tool stays open
    • show some indication in titlebar (eg add 'Hot folders')
    • disable manual input controls
      there is no reason to mix manual and automatic modes
    • disable Convert button
      guess its fine to have it that way as checkbox do the same thing, but I'm OK with Convert/Run changing to Stop as well
    hot_folder.png


ps. also 'Hot folders...' checkbox shall be disabled by default

Re: Hot folders -- Convert button only active when a file loaded on the Input tab

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 6:53 am
by cday
I will be posting some thoughts and a suggested solution when I have time.