'Auto image size' should be 'Auto image zoom'

[rotbus19]

'Auto image size' does not change image *size*, it changes the image zoom so should be renamed to 'Auto image zoom' for clarity.

EDIT - 'Auto zoom' would actually be better and fit with styling of 'Zoom in', 'Lock zoom', etc.

[user0]

+1
I would also shorten it to "Auto zoom", as
- context is alredy provided (we are in image viewing app)
- zooming may apply to video files in future

[rotbus19]

Fair point. What else would we be zooming other than an image?!

[cday]

View > Image size... might possibly be clearer, I think?

Looking at the available options, that would cover all but the last Fit window to image, wouldn't it?

[user0]

What else would we be zooming other than an image?!

video, maybe pdf

View > Image size... might possibly be clearer, I think?

Looking at the available options, that would cover all but the last Fit window to image, wouldn't it?

It does not (re)size image, it zooms image automatically to the window size.
Sizing only happens with 'Fit window to image' option and it affects window size.

Also there is similarly worded option already exists - Resize... (that shall be renamed to Resize image...)

[cday]

We probably agree that View > Auto image size... is not ideal, not immediately clear?

It does not (re)size image, it zooms image automatically to the window size.
Sizing only happens with 'Fit window to image' option and it affects window size.

Is there really a meaningful difference, Image size... seems clear to me?

Also there is similarly worded option already exists - Resize... (that shall be renamed to Resize image...)

I don't really see an issue with having both View > Image size... and Image > Resize ... or your proposal Image > Resize image....

But we all naturally prefer our own suggestions...

[rotbus19]

View > Auto image size... is not ideal, not immediately clear?

I'd go for misleading.

[xnview]

So 'Auto Zoom'?

[rotbus19]

So 'Auto Zoom'?

Yeah, 'Auto zoom'.

I also offered a few language suggestions, including this one, at viewtopic.php?p=196222#p196222 (in case you hadn't seen it).

[cday]

So 'Auto Zoom'?

For me, View > Auto Zoom... is not sufficiently clear, neither Auto nor to a lesser extent Zoom are really clear enough.

I prefer View > Image size... so:

View > Image size... > Fit image to window
View > Image size... > Fit image to window, large only
View > Image size... > Fit image to window, small only
View > Image size... > Fit image to width
View > Image size... > Fit image to Height
View > Image size... > Fit image to width or height
View > Image size... > Fit window to image

Those are all except the last image sizes, aren't they?

Edit:

If there is a general preference for 'zoom', I think View > Image zoom... would be better than Auto zoom...

But we should be thinking of which wording would be most clear to a new user of the software.

[xnview]

I agree that 'auto image size' is not good...
'Display settings'?

[cday]

I agree that 'auto image size' is not good...
'Display settings'?

Or maybe 'Display options...' as they are really options rather than settings, if you don't like the previous suggestions?

There are multiple options, but only one parameter that is 'set', the selected option, so actually 'Display setting...' (singular) would be more logical. Pedantic?

[user0]

Display settings / options

It sounds too general for only auto zooming items and if go this path, it feels like some other options shall be incorporated inside.

I think 'Auto' shall stay.
It can be 'Auto fit' (valid for all menu options), but since this submenu belongs to the zooming menu group I prefer 'Auto zoom' as simple and easy to understand (even if last option falls off the list).

words I do not like:
- 'image' - is redundant and missleading, as it not only affects content (image, hope video in future), but window size as well
- 'size' - I read it as size in pixels or file size in the first place, hence 'Auto size' is a little bit missleading for me

Few examples

ps. offtop, I also had an idea to regroup zoom items inside single Zoom menu, so no such hassle anymore
Zoom - group menu items

[cday]

Display settings / options
It sounds too general for only auto zooming items and if go this path, it feels like some other options shall be incorporated inside.

Somewhat agree, especially for settings...

I think 'Auto' shall stay.

But what is 'auto' about a user selecting an option??

'image' - is redundant as it is obvious that this affects image, moreover it shall affect video as well

'size' - I read it as size in pixels or file size in the first place, hence 'Auto size' is not

I'm sure there is some potential ambiguity in many menu items, hard to avoid when using short text...

But for a new user of the software, I think View > Image size... or something similar is clearest -- and in any case the meaning is immediately clear when clicking on the menu item, which is what users do...

Edit: I'll read the thread again later and suggest other possible options if you don't like that suggestion.

[rotbus19]

I prefer View > Image size... so:

But it's not image size that is being changed here. It's the zoom factor. And it's being offered as 'auto' options.

'Auto zoom...' is clear, succinct and precise.