1.8.2 - viewer - selection - issue with state indicator in Edit menu

*** Please report new bugs here! ***

Moderators: XnTriq, helmut, xnview, Dreamer

User avatar
user0
XnThusiast
Posts: 2222
Joined: Sat May 09, 2015 9:37 am

1.8.2 - viewer - selection - issue with state indicator in Edit menu

Post by user0 »

XnViewMP 1.8.2 64bit
Windows11 (24H2), display resolution 3840x2160, win scaling 150%

Viewer - selection
issue with indicator state in Selection - set size/size (Edit menu)

To reproduce:
1. open any image in Viewer

Issue A1
2. check state of items in Selection - set ratio
'Free' is activated by default, but
no state indicator (•) is visible
expected behavior:
state indicator should be visible

Issue A2
3. press A
'Free' will be reactivated and state indicator appear - OK
4. goto Selection - set ratio
- select '1.00 (1:1)'
'1.00 (1:1)' will be activated - OK
5. goto Selection - set ratio
there will be 2 state indicators: 'Free' and '1.00 (1:1)'
expected behavior:
'Free' should not remain selected after selecting any fixed ratio, but
it is better to add 'Fixed' option and auto select it in such case (see suggestion).


Issue B1
6. goto Selection - set size
- select any size, eg 8x6
selection will be resized to 8x6, but in vertical (portrait) orientation, not in default horizontal (album)
7. goto Selection - set ratio
there will be 2 state indicators: 'Free' and '1.00 (1:1)'
expected behavior:
there should be no state indicators visible in 'Selection - set ratio', but
it is better to add 'Fixed' option and auto select it in such case (see suggestion).

Issue B2
7. press W to swap W and H
it will produce incorrect result

Issue B3
7. resize (8x6) selection
8. goto Selection - set size
8x6 still has indicator
expected behavior:
status indicators should not be visible since selection is no longer 8x6


Suggestion
issue with 2 state indicators can be fixed by adding new 'Fixed' option (similar to Crop panel)
Viewer - selection - ratio - add Fixed option




Related
Top

Return to “New”