Option 'Copy of' determines file naming when pasting
Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 9:17 pm
In XnVie 1.92 there's a new option "Copy of" which controls whether the prefix "Copy of" is added when pasting a file nor not. This is good, but I would prefer the same behaviour in XnView as in Windows Explorer.
[quote="foxyshadis wrote in topic "Copy of?""]
Explorer never makes "copy of" files unless you copy/paste from the same folder. I agree that it makes sense to be consistent with explorer - in this case it should act the same as drag & drop, popping up the window with the thumbnails to ask what to do. Copy-paste creating copies within a folder makes sense though.[/quote]
When copying within one folder, the user wants to make a copy (backup) in the same folder and does not want to overwrite the existing file, in the other case the user does want to make a copy in a different directory and should be notified if the file already exists.
With the "Copy of" option you cannot make XnView work in a really useful and smart way (unless you offer a dialog with "Overwrite", "Rename", "Cancel" buttons which will make handling even worse).
So:
Couldn't we simply remove this new option and make XnView's copy and paste behaviour similar to MS Explorer?
[quote="foxyshadis wrote in topic "Copy of?""]
Explorer never makes "copy of" files unless you copy/paste from the same folder. I agree that it makes sense to be consistent with explorer - in this case it should act the same as drag & drop, popping up the window with the thumbnails to ask what to do. Copy-paste creating copies within a folder makes sense though.[/quote]
When copying within one folder, the user wants to make a copy (backup) in the same folder and does not want to overwrite the existing file, in the other case the user does want to make a copy in a different directory and should be notified if the file already exists.
With the "Copy of" option you cannot make XnView work in a really useful and smart way (unless you offer a dialog with "Overwrite", "Rename", "Cancel" buttons which will make handling even worse).
So:
Couldn't we simply remove this new option and make XnView's copy and paste behaviour similar to MS Explorer?