Page 1 of 1

UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 8:20 pm
by helmut
In XnView MP, it says "Close" and "Apply" in various dialogs. Instead of "Close" and "Apply" it should say "OK" and "Cancel". And: "OK" button is to the left of "Cancel" button.

Windows standard for buttons in modal dialogs is:
"OK" is for confirming and closing a modal dialog.
"Cancel" is for canceling and closing a modal dialog.
"Apply" is used when settings/changes made should be applied without closing the modal dialog.

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Wed Feb 09, 2011 5:42 pm
by budz45
Do you mean like in menus like from the menu bar Image>Adjust>'shadow & highlight' the "Close" and "Apply" there?

If so I understand what you mean

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Sat Feb 12, 2011 10:41 am
by helmut
budz45 wrote:Do you means like in menus like from the menu bar Image>Adjust>'shadow & highlight' the "Close" and "Apply" there?
Yes, that dialog for example. It's wrong in many places:
Tools > Search...
Tools > Export...
Tools > Batch Convert..
Tools > Upload on web

Image > Change Colour depth...
Image > Solarize...
Image > Enhance Colors...
...

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Sat Feb 12, 2011 2:14 pm
by budz45
Yes your certainly right. I think too, that it should be 'OK' and 'Cancel' especially for the inclusion of the 'Cancel'... :)

Not to worry, though, as all Pieree would have to do on this issue is a simple name change. The functions would remain the same :P

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2011 7:33 pm
by xnview
helmut wrote: Yes, that dialog for example. It's wrong in many places:
Tools > Search...
Tools > Export...
Tools > Batch Convert..
Tools > Upload on web

Image > Change Colour depth...
Image > Solarize...
Image > Enhance Colors...
...
Do you agree with that? I'm ok for Close=>Cancel

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2011 3:01 pm
by JohnFredC
I think of three actions:
  • • Close dialog and apply changes
    • Close dialog but do not apply (i.e., abandon) changes
    • Apply changes but do not close dialog

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2011 5:41 am
by Vapavite
Hello,
Yes Helmut. The term "Close" is still ambiguous in a dialog!
"OK" is for confirming and closing a modal dialog.
"Cancel" is for canceling and closing a modal dialog.
"Apply" is used when settings/changes made should be applied without closing the modal dialog.
Overview if the three buttons : Apply | Cancel | OK :arrow: FR : Appliquer | Annuler | OK (pas Fermer!)
"And:OK" button is to the left of "Cancel" button.
So yes xnveiw!
Do you agree with that? I'm ok for Close=>Cancel
NB : The Apply button will be necessary only under certain conditions!
"Apply" is used when the settings / changes must/ be applied without closing the modal dialog box.
"Apply" is used when the settings / changes are required or permitted (preview) be applied without closing the modal dialog box.

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2011 12:24 pm
by xnview
Please check XnViewMP 0.38

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2011 11:50 pm
by JohnFredC
What has changed, exactly?

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 12:00 am
by budz45
JohnFredC wrote:What has changed, exactly?
Well John, see and compare for yourself :P

MP 0.35
Image

VS.

MP 0.38
Image

So in English XnViewMP, it's now 'ok' & 'cancel' instead of 'apply' & 'close' ------just a small cosmetic name change can make a big difference in apps. Not fully sure about all the other areas of MP where this should have been updated too.

PS.> Just one tiny thing, in the 'Export' window (launched from Browser) it still says 'close' instead of 'cancel'.

Re: UI: Close & Apply should be OK & Cancel

Posted: Thu Jul 14, 2011 1:01 am
by JohnFredC
Thanks budz45!