Dreamer, thank you for your replies on this difficult topic.
Dreamer wrote:helmut wrote:Dreamer wrote:Again, [Options] button should be renamed to Formats or Format Options and it should be moved, next to Format: [ . . . ] maybe.
I disagree. "Options" button simply opens the options. It's pretty clear that the category "Formats" will be opened, already. Otherwise you would have to rename many other "Option" buttons, too.
It's not clear what options should be opened, it's below "Owerwrite", so I still think it's confusing and should be renamed or at least moved to the same row as Format [ JPEG \/ ] (here), we could enlarge [...] button above or even rename to [Browse], like this:
Code: Select all
Directory [ ] [Browse ]
Format [ JPEG \/ ] [Options]
Yes, this would make things a bit clearer. But main problem is all these controls on the dialog which makes things confusing, not this single Option button.
Dreamer wrote:I think also "[x] Use same path as original files" option is very important, for normal users. "Directory [ ]" should be greyed out then.
I think rather than having an extra checkbox XnView could simply put the current browser dir into the field "Output Directory" (I think this is what marsh actually meant in his above post.)
Dreamer wrote:helmut wrote:Dreamer wrote:Script: [submenu - last used scripts *] [Open] [Save] [Export]
There's three pages in the above draft. ?
Only header info (important info) should appear on several folder tabs.
OK, only for second page, if
this option would be on second page (Advanced operations), users could select last used scripts and see changes below immediately, it would be very useful, since it's just for "Advanced operations". Currently it's completely wrong placed in main "Batch convert" window.
Agreed.
Dreamer wrote:Edit * - one item in submenu could be (if possible) e.g. "No actions" (same as "remove all" button, not very important)
It could look like this:
Code: Select all
Script: [C:\Program Files\bla.xbs ] [V] [...] [Save...]
Dreamer wrote:helmut wrote:Many people will wonder, what this at first empty and unlabeled drop down list is good for.
It would be clear with
my solution above.
So...
I think this solution is the best:
- 1st page/tab - Input / Output (with the change above)
- 2nd page/tab - Scripts row and 'Advanced operations" below
I was about writing something like
"I see no reason why "Advanced operations" tab and "Scripts" tab should be mixed into one tab." Before finishing the sentence I checked to see what is contained in the .xbs file. The .xbs file contains the list of advanced operations (=transformations) and the parameters, only. The list of files is not contained. So in fact it's not a script but simply a list of transformations which is saved and loaded. The term "Script" is not quite right, I think. Placing it on the "Transformation" page and renaming it to something like "Load transformations..." and "Save Transformations..." (or simply "Load..." and "Save...") would make this clear.
The "Export as NConvert script..." button is difficult. The script exported for NConvert is actually a real Batch script and will contain both transformations and the list of files. So I'm not sure whether the position on the "Transformation" tab is good.
One more confusing thing in the "Batch Convert" dialog which should be corrected: "Save script..." is at top and "Open script.." button at the bottom, in "Slide show.." dialog it's the other way round. Not our main issue, but another piece of the puzzle.
I think we are on the right track...
Dig in the mud and you will find more mud.