This is a suggestion for both XnView and XnViewMP. libimagequant is a BSD licensed library that is tremendously better than the basic Adaptive, Dithered, etc currently in XnView. Anyone who uses them has to admit, the current color reduction methods are holdovers from the 90's, and they aren't very good, often horribly discoloring images at lower depths and creating ugly patterns. All of them could be replaced by this much superior version, except that libimagequant is slower. It'd still be an excellent default, though.
Further, with this, you don't have to convert to palettized color. In fact you never had to, it's just one option, but XnView does anyway, completely destroying any alpha channel.
Comparisons:
libimagequant (19,996):
XnView (20,297, 128 color adaptive):
(Turned transparency off because it was just too ugly with it on.)
The difference just magnifies the more you quantize the color.
Replace GIF/PNG color reduction with libimagequant
Moderators: XnTriq, helmut, xnview
-
- Posts: 394
- Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006 8:57 am
-
- Posts: 127
- Joined: Thu Feb 10, 2011 1:52 pm
- Location: Hamburg
Re: Replace GIF/PNG color reduction with libimagequant
Random observations: pngquant.org/ shows your examples and offers various tools. The PhotoShop plugin is an 8BI, XnView can't handle that (= supports only 32bit 8BF). To see what you are talking about I tested x128 cq.exe (color quantizer, there's a new version 2014-11-29, I still had the predecessor) and also tested XnView convert to 256 dither none + floyd-steinberg, edit palette transparency on 0, save as PNG.
Summary: You have a point. I'd like an improved variant also supporting more than 256 colours, because XPM (unlike GIF, or PNG with palette) is not limited to 256.
Update: There's also an older French article comparing pngquant, XnView, truepng, cq, imagemagick, gimp, etc.
Summary: You have a point. I'd like an improved variant also supporting more than 256 colours, because XPM (unlike GIF, or PNG with palette) is not limited to 256.
Update: There's also an older French article comparing pngquant, XnView, truepng, cq, imagemagick, gimp, etc.
-
- Moderator & Librarian
- Posts: 6366
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2005 3:00 am
- Location: Ref Desk
Re: Replace GIF/PNG color reduction with libimagequant
Testing TinyPNG earlier this year left me puzzled. Thanks for clearing that up!
- XnView bug tracker
- 0000551: Libquant